About The Mustard Company Store

Selling mustards and condiments in beautiful downtown Dyersburg, TN. Our shop features unique food items, sauces and gifts. Our specialty is our own Tigertail & Dyer Mills Brand made in Dyersburg, TN by Develey USA.

All Our Brands

Most Popular Products

Pantry Items

Refine by

Sort by

Filters

Filters

Availability

Availability

In stock

125

Carmie's Black Cherry Vanilla Cheesecake Dip

$4.50

Too Good Gourmet Skillet Set

$11.00

Ariston Select Extra Virgin Olive Oil

$10.98

Ariston Chili Infused Olive Oil

$11.98

Ariston Lemon Infused Extra Virgin Olive Oil

$11.98

Ariston Itailian Herb Dipping Oil

$13.98

Carmie's Tasty Taco Soup

$8.00

Amish Country Dill Pickle Popcorn Seasoning

$6.10

Amish Country Maple Bacon BBQ seasoning

$6.10

Amish Country Sea Salt & Caramel

$6.10

Amish Country Hickory Smoke BBQ

$6.10

Amish Country Garlic Parmesan

$6.10

Dyer Co Brand Strawberry Butter 19oz

$7.99

Dyer Co Brand Tomato & Basil

$7.99

Dyer Co Brand Sweet & Sour Dressing

$6.99

Dyer Co Brand Lemon Herb Dressing

$6.99

Dyer Co Brand Cherry Butter

$5.25

Dyer Co Brand Cherry Berry Jam 9oz

$5.25

Dyer Co Brand Rum Apple Butter

$5.25

Dyer Co Brand French Onion Dip

$5.99